Inspection
- annual renewal of practising certificates
- annual renewal of CPA Firm, Corporate Practice and PIE Auditor registrations; and
- application for registration as a Registered PIE Auditor.
-
Policy and Oversight
-
Registration
-
Inspection
-
Investigations & Enquiries
-
Discipline
Non-PIE Auditors
- The Accounting and Financial Reporting Council (“AFRC”) is an independent body established under the Accounting and Financial Reporting Council Ordinance (Cap. 588) (“AFRCO”).
- Under Part 3AA Division 2 of the AFRCO, the AFRC is empowered to carry out inspections in relation to a practice unit (“Regulatee”) for the purpose of determining whether the Regulatee has observed, maintained or applied PAO professional standards.
- Please note that a registered PIE auditor is also a practice unit (hence a Regulatee). However, it should be noted that the AFRC has separate powers of inspection under Part 3A of the AFRCO in relation to “PIE engagements” (as defined in section 3A(1) of the AFRCO), and this Policy Statement is not applicable to such inspections. For details of the AFRC's policy for inspections in relation to PIE auditors with respect to PIE engagements, please refer to the “Policy Statement for Inspection of PIE Auditors with respect to PIE Engagements”, which is available on the AFRC’s website (www.afrc.org.hk).
Definitions
- In this Policy Statement, the following terms have the meanings defined in the AFRCO as set out below (the definitions in the AFRCO shall prevail in case of any inconsistency):
Terms |
Meanings defined in the AFRCO |
Section under the AFRCO |
certified public accountant (“CPA”) |
A CPA means a person registered as a certified public accountant by virtue of section 22 of the Professional Accountants Ordinance (Cap. 50) (“PA Ordinance”). |
2(1) |
CPA firm
|
A CPA firm means:
|
2(1) |
CPA inspector
|
An CPA inspector means a person appointed as a CPA inspector under section 20ZZA of the AFRCO. |
2(1) |
certified public accountant (practising) (“CPA (practising)”) |
A CPA (practising) means a CPA holding a practising certificate. |
2(1) |
corporate practice |
A corporate practice means a company registered as a corporate practice under Division 3 of Part 2A of the AFRCO. |
2(1) |
PAO professional standard
|
A PAO professional standard means any statement of professional ethics, or standard of accounting, auditing or assurance practices, issued or specified, or deemed to have been issued or specified, under section 18A of the PA Ordinance. |
2(1) |
public interest entity (“PIE”)
|
A PIE means a listed corporation the listed securities of which comprise at least shares or stocks, or a listed collective investment scheme. |
3(1) |
PIE engagement |
A PIE engagement means any of the following types of engagements for the preparation of:
|
3A; Part 1 of Schedule 1A |
practice unit |
A practice unit means:
|
2(1) |
professional person |
A professional person means a CPA or a practice unit. |
2(1) |
registered PIE auditor |
A registered PIE auditor means a practice unit registered under Division 2 of part 3. |
3A(1) |
Purpose of this document
- The purpose of this Policy Statement is to provide an overview of the legal regime of the inspection function of the AFRC for Regulatees, under Part 3AA Division 2 of the AFRCO.
- For details of the AFRC’s inspection process in relation to practice units that are not PIE auditors, please refer to the “Outline of the AFRC’s Inspection Process for Practice Units that are not PIE Auditors”, which is available on the AFRC’s website (www.afrc.org.hk).
Objectives of an inspection
- The AFRC is entrusted with the statutory duty to regulate the accountancy profession. An effective regulatory regime of the accountancy profession is crucial for the business community and is essential for maintaining Hong Kong’s status as an international financial centre.
- The AFRC may direct a CPA inspector to carry out an inspection in relation to a Regulatee for the purpose of determining whether the Regulatee has observed, maintained or applied a specified PAO professional standard. The objectives of such inspections are to monitor and promote the quality of professional accounting work in Hong Kong, by ensuring Regulatees are acting in accordance with PAO professional standards.
Circumstances in which inspections may be conducted
- Pursuant to section 20ZZB(1)(a) and (1)(b) of the AFRCO, the AFRC may specify a PAO professional standard in relation which an inspection is to be carried out, and direct a CPA inspector to carry out an inspection in relation to a Regulatee for the purpose of determining whether the Regulatee has observed, maintained or applied the PAO professional standard. Pursuant to section 2(1) of the AFRCO, a PAO professional standard means any statement of professional ethics, standard of accounting, auditing or assurance practices, issued or specified, or deemed to have been issued or specified, under section 18A of the PA Ordinance. PAO standards include the “Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants” published by The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants, which contains the “Guidelines on Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing for Professional Accountants”. (Section 2(1) and 20ZZB of the AFRCO)
- An inspection may cover specific aspects of an engagement of a Regulatee, or the system of quality control and practice of a Regulatee generally.
- Pursuant to section 20ZZB(1)(c) of the AFRCO, the AFRC may also determine the practices and procedures to be followed for the inspection. (Section 20ZZB of the AFRCO)
Powers of a CPA inspector
- Pursuant to section 20ZZC of the AFRCO, a CPA inspector has the power to require a specified person (a "Specified Person") to: (Section 20ZZC of the AFRCO)
-
- produce to the CPA inspector, or give the CPA inspector access to, within the time and at the place specified in the requirement, any specified document in their possession or under their control, that the CPA inspector has reasonable cause to believe to be relevant to the inspection (a "required document");
- give to the CPA inspector such explanation or further particulars in respect of the required document as the CPA inspector specifies; and
- give to the CPA inspector all assistance in connection with the inspection that the Specified Person is reasonably able to give.
- A CPA inspector may also inspect, examine or make copies of a required document, and take any abstract of, or extract from, a required document. (Section 20ZZC of the AFRCO)
- A Specified Person is any of the following persons, whom the CPA inspector has reasonable cause to believe to be in possession of, or in control of, a required document: (Section 20ZZC of the AFRCO)
-
- if the practice unit to which the inspection relates is a CPA (practising) who practises accountancy on the accountant's own account, that accountant;
- if the practice unit to which the inspection relates is a firm of CPA (practising) or a corporate practice, a certified public accountant working in the practice unit; and
- any person who is employed by, or whose services are engaged by, the practice unit to which the inspection relates.
- A specified document means any record or document specified by the CPA inspector, or any record or document that is of a class or description specified by a CPA inspector. (Section 20ZZC of the AFRCO)
- Regulatees shall cooperate with the AFRC in all of its regulatory processes, including the inspection process, and to comply with any requirements imposed by a CPA inspector under section 20ZZC of the AFRCO. A failure on the part of a professional person without reasonable excuse to comply with a requirement imposed under section 20ZZC constitutes a professional irregularity under section 3B of the AFRCO, and may result in the imposition of disciplinary sanctions. (Section 3B of the AFRCO)
Inspection report
- At the conclusion of an inspection, a CPA inspector is required by section 20ZZD of the AFRCO to prepare and submit to the AFRC a written report. If required by the AFRC, a CPA inspector must also prepare and submit to the AFRC a written report at any other stage of the inspection. (Section 20ZZD of the AFRCO)
- Before submitting an inspection report to the AFRC, the CPA inspector must send a dated draft of the report to (i) the Regulatee concerned and (ii) any other person(s) named in the draft report, and give them a reasonable opportunity of being heard. Please refer to the “Outline of the AFRC’s Inspection Process for Practice Units that are not PIE Auditors”, which is available on the AFRC’s website (www.afrc.org.hk), for details in relation to the opportunity of being heard. (Section 20ZZD of the AFRCO)
- After submitting the inspection report to the AFRC, the CPA inspector will send the same to (i) the Regulatee concerned, and (ii) any other person(s) named in the report. (Section 20ZZD of the AFRCO)
Follow-up action
- Pursuant to section 20ZZE, the AFRC may, having regard to an inspection report in relation to a Regulatee: (Section 20ZZE of the AFRCO)
-
- decide no follow-up action is required;
- require a Regulatee to take a measure or corrective action regarding compliance with a PAO professional standard;
- direct a CPA inspector to carry out a further inspection under Part 3AA Division 2 of the AFRCO;
- initiate an investigation under section 20ZZH of the AFRCO; or
- impose a sanction on, or take an action in relation to, the Regulatee or any CPA to which the inspection relates under sections 37CA or 37I(1A) of the AFRCO.
- This document provides a summary for reference only. It is not legal advice. Regulatees should seek their own legal advice. In the event of any inconsistency between this document and the AFRCO, the AFRCO shall prevail.
- The Accounting and Financial Reporting Council (“AFRC”) is an independent body established under the Accounting and Financial Reporting Council Ordinance (Cap. 588) (“AFRCO”).
- The purpose of this Policy Statement is to provide an overview of the legal regime of the AFRC's powers to conduct inspections in relation to compliance with the anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing requirements applicable to accounting professionals.
Definitions
- In this Policy Statement, the following terms have the meanings defined in the AFRCO as set out below (the definitions in the AFRCO shall prevail in case of any inconsistency):
Terms |
Meanings defined in the AFRCO |
Section under the AFRCO |
AML/CTF requirement |
An AML/CTF requirement means a requirement set out in Part 2, 3 or 4 of Schedule 2 to the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing Ordinance (Cap. 615) as may be applicable. |
3B(5) |
certified public accountant (“CPA”) |
A CPA means a person registered as a certified public accountant by virtue of section 22 of the Professional Accountants Ordinance (Cap. 50) (“PA Ordinance”). |
2(1) |
CPA firm |
A CPA firm means:
|
2(1) |
certified public accountant (practising) (“CPA (practising)”) |
A CPA (practising) means a CPA holding a practising certificate. |
2(1) |
corporate practice |
A corporate practice means a company registered as a corporate practice under Division 3 of Part 2A of the AFRCO. |
2(1) |
Listing Rules |
The Listing Rules mean:
approved by the Securities and Futures Commission under section 24 of the Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571), and as in force at the material time. |
2(1) |
public interest entity (“PIE”)
|
A PIE means a listed corporation the listed securities of which comprise at least shares or stocks, or a listed collective investment scheme. |
3(1) |
PIE auditor |
A PIE auditor means a registered or recognized PIE auditor. |
3A |
PIE engagement |
A PIE engagement means any of the following types of engagements for the preparation of:
|
3A; Part 1 of Schedule 1A |
non-PIE |
A non-PIE means a listed corporation the listed securities of which do not comprise shares or stocks. |
3(1) |
non-PIE auditor |
A non-PIE auditor means a practice unit that undertakes or carries out a non-PIE engagement. |
3A |
non-PIE engagement
|
A non-PIE engagement means any of the following types of engagements for the preparation of:
|
3A; Part 2 of Schedule 1A |
PAO professional standard
|
A PAO professional standard means any statement of professional ethics, or standard of accounting, auditing or assurance practices, issued or specified, or deemed to have been issued or specified, under section 18A of the PA Ordinance. |
2(1) |
professional standard
|
A professional standard means:
|
2(1) |
professional person |
A professional person means a CPA or a practice unit. |
2(1) |
registered responsible person |
A registered responsible person means any of the following individuals whose name is recorded in the PIE auditors register as a responsible person of a registered PIE auditor:
|
2(1) |
Inspections regarding compliance with anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing requirements
- The AFRC is entrusted with the statutory duty to regulate the accountancy profession. An effective regulatory regime of the accounting profession is crucial for the business community and is essential for maintaining Hong Kong’s status as an international financial centre.
- The Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing Ordinance (Cap. 615) (“AMLO”) is one of the key legislations setting out Hong Kong's legal framework on anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing.
- The AMLO imposes various AML/CTF requirements, including customer due diligence (“CDD”) and record-keeping requirements, with which financial institutions and “designated non-financial businesses and professions” (“DNFBPs”) must comply. (Section 5A of the AMLO)
- Under the AMLO, DNFBPs are defined to include an “accounting professional” (“accounting professional”), which in turn is defined to mean a CPA, a CPA (practising), a corporate practice or a CPA firm. As the definition of “accounting professional” in the AMLO and the definition of “professional person” in the AFRCO cover the same range of persons and entities in the accounting profession, the rest of this policy statement will, for the sake of clarity, refer only to “professional persons” in the context of AML/CTF requirements. (Schedule 1, Part 2, Section 1 of the AMLO)
- The AFRC and the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (“HKICPA”) have both been designated as a “regulatory body” under AMLO in respect of compliance by professional persons with the CDD and record-keeping requirements under AMLO. The AFRC would carry out inspections for the purpose of ascertaining compliance with such CDD and record-keeping requirements and the HKICPA may publish any guideline that it considers appropriate for providing guidance in relation to the operation of such CDD and record-keeping requirements. (Schedule 1, Part 2, Section 1 of the AMLO)
- In this regard, the HKICPA has published its “Guidelines on Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing for Professional Accountants” (“AML Guidelines”), which form part of the HKICPA’s “Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants” (“Code of Ethics”).
- The Code of Ethics (including the AML Guidelines) constitutes a PAO professional standard (hence also a professional standard) under the AFRCO. (Section 2(1) of the AFRCO)
- Therefore, the AFRC may make use of its powers under the AFRCO to carry out inspections under both Part 3A (of PIE auditors in respect of PIE engagements) and Part 3AA (of practice units in respect of engagements other than PIE engagements) for the purpose of ascertaining compliance with the AML Guidelines.
- For the AFRC’s policy and high-level procedures for inspections, please refer to (i) the “Policy Statement for Inspection of PIE Auditors with respect to PIE Engagements”; (ii) the “Outline of the AFRC’s Inspection Process for PIE Auditors”; (iii) the “Policy Statement for Inspection of Practice Units with respect to engagements other than PIE Engagements”; and (iv) the “Outline of the AFRC’s Inspection Process for Practice Units that are not PIE Auditors”, which are available on the AFRC’s website (www.afrc.org.hk).
- Pursuant to section 3B of the AFRCO, a failure by a professional person to comply with an applicable AML/CTF requirement constitutes a professional irregularity, and may result in the imposition of disciplinary sanctions. (Section 3B of the AFRCO)
- Pursuant to section 4 of the AFRCO, a failure or neglect to observe, maintain or otherwise apply the AML Guidelines (which, as indicated above, constitutes a professional standard) by (i) a PIE auditor or non-PIE auditor (whether it is a corporate practice, a CPA (practising), or a firm of CPAs (practising)), or (ii) a registered responsible person of a registered PIE auditor, in relation to PIE engagements completed on or after 1 October 2019, constitutes a practice irregularity, and may result in the imposition of disciplinary sanctions. (Section 4 of the AFRCO)
- This document provides a summary for reference only. It is not legal advice. Persons concerned should seek their own legal advice. In the event of any inconsistency between this document and the AFRCO, the AFRCO shall prevail.
(i) Assessment
The AFRC will conduct inspections from time to time. When deciding whether to inspect a particular Regulatee in any particular year, and the ambit of the inspection to be carried out, the AFRC will consider, amongst other things:
- the AFRC's assessment of the risks associated with the Regulatee's practice based on available information (including the results of any prior inspection);
- the size of the Regulatee, including but not limited to the number of clients and practising partners or directors of the Regulatee during that period;
- the complexity of the practice and the engagements of the Regulatee;
- the Regulatee's regulatory history;
- the period of time since the Regulatee was lasted inspected by the AFRC; and/or
- the AFRC's available resources.
For the AFRC's determination of the frequency of inspection, the AFRC may from time to time require a Regulatee to provide information relating to the Regulatee and its practices.
(ii) Manner of inspection
The CPA inspector will conduct an inspection in relation to a Regulatee either by way of (i) an on-site inspection, or (ii) a desktop review. Desktop review is generally carried out for practice units which do not have certain predetermined risk factors, e.g., whether or not the practice unit audits licensed corporations or brokerage clients or more than a certain number of audits, etc.
In the context of an on-site inspection, the CPA inspector will conduct the inspection at the Regulatee's registered office or other registered place of business.
In the context of a desktop review, the inspection takes place remotely at the AFRC's office by way of the CPA inspector reviewing such information, records and documents of the Regulatee as requested.
The AFRC has the power to appoint, in writing, an employee of the AFRC, or any other person with the consent of the Financial Secretary, as a CPA inspector for the purposes of the AFRCO.
Before the start of an inspection, a CPA inspector will notify the Regulatee in writing of the time and manner the AFRC plans to conduct the inspection.
A CPA inspector may also request the Regulatee to provide certain basic information to assist in planning the inspection, including but not limited to information about the Regulatee's clients, engagements, personnel and quality control system.
The inspection may be conducted in phases if the AFRC considers it necessary in the circumstances, and a CPA inspector will notify the Regulatee accordingly.
On-site inspection
The on-site inspection fieldwork will be carried out at a reasonable time (usually during office hours), and at the Regulatee's registered office or other registered place of business. It is expected that the CPA inspector will be provided with adequate office facilities and the Regulatee's assistance to enable the inspection to be performed effectively and efficiently.
Desktop review
A desktop review will be carried out by the CPA inspector at the AFRC's office.
Notwithstanding the manner of inspection, the Regulatee shall comply with its statutory duties and fully cooperate with the CPA inspector at all times during the inspection, including but not limited to:
- produce or give access to the CPA inspector any specified document in such person's possession or control that the CPA inspector has reasonable cause to believe to be relevant to the inspection;
- give the CPA inspector such explanation or particulars in respect of the specified document required; and
- give the CPA inspector all assistance in connection with the inspection that such person is reasonably able to give.
At the conclusion of an inspection, the CPA inspector will prepare an inspection report, which will be submitted to the AFRC (see Stage 4). If required by the AFRC, the inspector will prepare an inspection report at any other stage of the inspection and submit the report to the AFRC.
The CPA inspector must give the Regulatee and any other person(s) named in the draft inspection report (the "Other Named Persons") a reasonable opportunity to be heard in respect of the matters set out in the draft inspection report, before inspection report is submitted to the AFRC. This will be done by allowing the Regulatee to make representations in respect of the draft inspection report. The Regulatee and any Other Named Persons will be informed of this right when the draft inspection report is sent to them for this purpose.
Under normal circumstances, the Regulatee and any Other Named Persons will be given 21 days to make any representations in writing. However, if the Regulatee or any Other Named Persons considers it necessary to make oral representations, they may request a meeting with the inspector. Such a meeting will only be held if the CPA inspector considers fairness in the circumstances requires it.
The Regulatee and any Other Named Persons may make such representations to the CPA inspector as they consider appropriate. However, if the Regulatee or any Other Named Persons does not agree with the contents set out in the draft inspection report, they should identify the matters with which they disagree and explain why they disagree. They should further provide any evidence in their possession which may substantiate their representations.
When all representations have been received or the deadline for making representations has otherwise passed, the CPA inspector will consider any representations from the Regulatee and any Other Named Persons which have been submitted. The CPA inspector may modify the draft inspection report in the light of such representations.
The CPA inspector shall then finalise the inspection report, and submit the final inspection report to the AFRC. After submission, the CPA inspector will send the final inspection report to the Regulatee and any Other Named Persons.
If it is necessary, the Regulatee will be asked to make a proposal to the AFRC in respect of the remedial actions the Regulatee intends to take in response to the inspection report.
Having regard to the final inspection report, and the Regulatee's proposed remedial actions (if any), the AFRC will determine whether to take any follow-up actions under section 20ZZE of Part 3AA of the AFRCO (and if so what actions to take).
- Under Part 3AA of the Accounting and Financial Reporting Council Ordinance (Cap. 588) ("AFRCO"), the Accounting and Financial Reporting Council (“AFRC”) is empowered to carry out inspections in relation to practice units (“Regulatees”) for the purpose of determining whether the Regulatees have observed, maintained or applied a PAO professional standard(s).
- Pursuant to section 2(1) of the AFRCO, PAO professional standards include the “Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants” published by The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants, which contain the “Guidelines on Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing for Professional Accountants” (“AML/CTF Guidelines”). Therefore, inspections under Part 3AA of the AFRCO may consider compliance with the AML/CTF Guidelines.
- For information about the AFRC’s inspection powers, please refer to the AFRC’s (i) “Policy Statement for Inspection of Practice Units with respect to engagements other than PIE Engagements”; and (ii) “Policy Statement for Inspection of Practice Units with respect to compliance with Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing Requirements”, which are available on the AFRC’s website (afrc.org.hk).
- This document is intended to provide a brief overview of the AFRC’s inspection process for inspections under Part 3AA of the AFRCO in relation to Regulatees, which has been designed to ensure that all Regulatees other than PIE auditors, are treated fairly and impartially.
- Please note that a registered PIE auditor is also a practice unit (hence a Regulatee). However, it should be noted that the AFRC has separate powers of inspection under Part 3A of the AFRCO in relation to "PIE engagements" (as defined in section 3A(1) of the AFRCO). This Outline is not applicable to the PIE engagements conducted by PIE auditors. For an outline of the inspection process in relation to such PIE auditors, please refer to the “Outline of the AFRC’s Inspection Process for PIE Auditors”, which is available on the AFRC’s website (afrc.org.hk).
Definitions
- In this document, the following terms have the meanings defined in the AFRCO as set out below (the definitions in the AFRCO shall prevail in case of any inconsistency):
Terms |
Meanings defined in the AFRCO |
Section under the AFRCO |
certified public accountant (“CPA”)
|
A CPA means a person registered as a certified public accountant by virtue of section 22 of the Professional Accountants Ordinance (Cap. 50) (“PA Ordinance”).
|
2(1) |
CPA firm
|
A CPA firm means:
· a CPA (practising) who practises accountancy on the accountant's own account under a firm name registered under Division 2 of Part 2A of the AFRCO; or · a firm of CPAs (practising) that practises accountancy in partnership and is registered under Division 2 of Part 2A of the AFRCO.
|
2(1) |
CPA inspector
|
An CPA inspector means a person appointed as a CPA inspector under section 20ZZA of the AFRCO.
|
2(1) |
certified public accountant (practising) (“CPA (practising)”)
|
A CPA (practising) means a CPA holding a practising certificate. |
2(1) |
corporate practice |
A corporate practice means a company registered as a corporate practice under Division 3 of Part 2A of the AFRCO.
|
2(1) |
PAO professional standard
|
A PAO professional standard means any statement of professional ethics, or standard of accounting, auditing or assurance practices, issued or specified, or deemed to have been issued or specified, under section 18A of the PA Ordinance.
|
2(1) |
practice unit |
A practice unit means:
· a CPA (practising) who practises accountancy on the accountant's own account under the accountant's own name as registered under section 22(2) of the PA Ordinance; · a CPA firm; or · a corporate practice.
|
2(1) |
registered PIE auditors
|
A registered PIE auditor means a practice unit registered under Division 2 of Part 3.
|
3A(1) |
7. This document provides a summary for reference only. It is not legal advice. Persons concerned should seek their own legal advice. In the event of any inconsistency between this document and the AFRCO, the AFRCO shall prevail.